6 Best ReplyGuy Alternatives in 2026
ReplyGuy posts Reddit replies from accounts it bought. Six alternatives that write the reply and let you post it yourself. Prices as of 31 Oct 2026.
We make FounderDive, and we list it first. Every other tool here is described from its own site, checked on 31 Oct 2026. Prices change; follow the links and check before you buy.
ReplyGuy is hands-off: it finds posts, writes a reply that mentions your product, and posts it. Its own FAQ says Reddit replies go out from accounts it bought. In 2024, 404 Media reported that Reddit called this kind of posting content manipulation, and the example accounts it found were banned.
Every alternative below drafts the reply and leaves posting to you, from your own account. We make FounderDive and list it first. If you specifically want someone else to post for you, none of these does that.
How we picked
- Writes or suggests a reply
- Does not post replies for you
- Price from the tool's own site, dated
1. FounderDive
Founders who want the reply written for them and posted by them, from their own account.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- Free first hunt; Starter $29.99/mo; Pro $79.99/mo
- Posts for you?
- No
Good at
- Looks in nine places, Reddit first, and keeps only posts that score 72 or more out of 100
- Writes each reply only from facts you gave it; a draft that can't cite one is thrown away
- Eight safety checks on every reply, including group rules, 9 helpful replies per 1 that mentions you, and a shadowban check
Watch out for
- Never posts for you, and some buyers want that. You press send from your own account
- No keyword or brand-mention alerts, no Slack, and X only through Google's index
- Young product with no public customer numbers; almost all kept posts come from Reddit
2. Ryphor
Many sites, replies drafted from your own documents, and a no-card trial.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- Early-access Starter $24.50/mo, Pro $49.50/mo, Growth $64.50/mo
- Posts for you?
- No
Good at
- Reddit, Hacker News, Indie Hackers, Stack Exchange and SourceForge on every plan; X, Bluesky, Instagram, Threads, G2 and more on Pro
- Drafts replies from documents you upload, and never posts
- Posting-pace tracker and a flag on groups that ban self-promotion; trial of 7 days with no card
Watch out for
- Young product; the early-access price is a discount on higher list prices
3. ReplyGain
Low-cost scheduled scans of Reddit, Hacker News, X and Bluesky with drafted replies.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- Starter $22/mo; Pro $59/mo; Business $149/mo; 7-Day Pass $9
- Posts for you?
- No
Good at
- Scans on a schedule, every 12 to 2 hours by plan, without you pressing anything
- High monthly volumes: 1,000 leads and 1,000 replies on Starter
- The $9 week pass is refunded if it finds no leads in 3 days
Watch out for
- No safety checks listed on its site that we could find
- No free plan
4. RedShip
A Reddit inbox with keyword and competitor tracking, Slack alerts and an MCP server.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- Founder $29/mo; Company $49/mo; 7-Day Pass $12 one-time
- Posts for you?
- No
Good at
- Tracks your site, keywords and competitors on Reddit and suggests replies, with no limit on suggestions
- Email and Slack alerts, a REST API and an MCP server
- Weekly reports on Reddit posts that rank on Google and get cited by AI tools
Watch out for
- Reddit only
- No free plan or trial; the cheapest way in is the $12 pass
5. Subreddit Signals
Watching a short list of subreddits you choose, through Reddit's official API.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- Starter $29/mo; Pro $59/mo; trial of 14 days, card required
- Posts for you?
- No
Good at
- Reads the subreddits you pick through Reddit's official API
- Clear scoring: five scores plus a buying stage, explained on a public page
- Drafts replies in a voice profile you set; says plainly it doesn't auto-post
Watch out for
- Reddit only, and only up to 10 or 25 subreddits
- Drafts limited by weekly tokens; trial needs a card
- Its separate Mochi product does publish posts on a schedule
6. Redreach
Finding Reddit posts that rank on Google, plus brand and competitor tracking.
- Price (as of 31 Oct 2026)
- From $19/mo per its own site; plan prices we couldn't confirm
- Posts for you?
- Optional
Good at
- Finds Reddit posts that already rank on Google or show buying intent, scored out of 100
- Tracks your brand and 3 competitors; alerts by email, Slack, Telegram or webhook
- Money back within 48 hours of payment
Watch out for
- Reddit only
- Its Outbound Chrome extension sends DMs in bulk, which we think puts accounts at risk
- Full plan prices aren't in its page source; third-party sites disagree
Questions
Is there a ReplyGuy alternative that posts for me?
Not on this list. Every tool here leaves posting to you. Redreach's Outbound extension sends DMs in bulk, but not public replies.
Why post from my own account?
Because the trust a good reply earns stays with you, and the account is one you control. Replies from accounts that aren't yours can be removed or banned with nothing you can do about it.
What does ReplyGuy cost?
From $49 a month, plus credits: 1 per post found, 3 per reply posted and 5 per DM (as of 31 Oct 2026). It offers a trial at no charge on every plan; the length isn't stated.
Can I try FounderDive free?
Yes. Your first hunt is free with no card: every post it finds is readable in full and it writes up to 20 replies. There is no trial after that. Starter is $29.99 a month and Pro $79.99 (as of 31 Oct 2026).